Is This Person Trustworthy? A 5-Point Checklist for People-Pleasers

The Hidden Trust Crisis Among People-Pleasers | Why Trust Feels So Hard

You've spent years replaying conversations, second-guessing your gut, and wondering if you're "too sensitive." Sound familiar?

As a people-pleaser, trust feels confusing because you've learned to measure safety by other people's approval instead of your own sense of ease. You might find yourself drawn to people who need you, who praise your helpfulness, or who make you feel important through their dependence.

But approval isn't the same as trustworthiness. And being needed isn't the same as being valued.

When you've been conditioned to prioritize others' comfort over your own boundaries, it becomes incredibly difficult to distinguish between people who genuinely care about your wellbeing and those who simply benefit from your people-pleasing patterns.

The result? You might feel drained by relationships that should energize you, confused about why "nice" people leave you feeling hollow, or uncertain whether your instincts about someone can be trusted.

There Is a Solution: The 5-Point Trustworthiness Checklist in Holistic Counseling

Trustworthy people share common traits, regardless of personality type or communication style. In holistic counseling sessions, I often teach clients to look for these five markers when evaluating relationships:

1. Considerate
   They respect your needs without guilt-tripping you. When you say no or express a preference, they don't make you feel selfish or demanding. They might be disappointed, but they don't punish you for having boundaries.

2. Sincere
   Their words and actions match consistently over time. They don't promise things they can't deliver, and they don't say what they think you want to hear just to avoid conflict.

3. Responsible
   They own their mistakes instead of blaming, deflecting, or gaslighting. When they mess up, they acknowledge it genuinely and take steps to repair any harm caused.

4. Reliable
   They follow through on their commitments, both big and small. If they say they'll call, they call. If they commit to something, they show up or communicate clearly if plans change.

5. Competent
   They manage their own emotional life without making you their unpaid therapist. While they might seek support during difficult times, they don't consistently dump their problems on you or expect you to fix their feelings.

Your First Win: Recognizing Trust Patterns in Relationships

When you start using this checklist, something powerful happens: you begin to notice patterns you've been unconsciously ignoring.

Some people in your life consistently show up with these traits - and you'll notice that your nervous system can actually relax around them. You don't find yourself walking on eggshells or rehearsing conversations. You don't leave interactions feeling drained or confused.

Others? They consistently fail to meet these markers, and suddenly it makes sense why you feel exhausted after spending time with them. It's not because you're "too sensitive" - it's because they can't (or won't) meet you in a place of mutual respect and responsibility.

This recognition alone can be incredibly validating for people-pleasers who have spent years questioning their own perceptions.

The Next Layer: Seeing Clearly Through People-Pleasing Patterns

Here's what many of my therapy clients discover once they start identifying truly trustworthy people: they also become acutely aware of how much energy they've been giving to relationships that aren't reciprocal or healthy.

You might realize that certain friendships have been one-sided for years. Or that family members consistently guilt-trip you when you try to set boundaries. Or that colleagues take credit for your work while positioning themselves as mentors.

This awareness can initially feel overwhelming - especially when you recognize these patterns in long-standing relationships or professional connections that feel difficult to change.

The question becomes: now that you can see these dynamics clearly, what do you do with this information? How do you navigate relationships with people who aren't trustworthy but remain part of your life? And how do you start building connections with people who can actually meet you with the same level of consideration and respect you offer them?

For executives and high-achieving women, this challenge becomes even more complex when workplace success has often depended on managing up, anticipating others' needs, and maintaining harmony even at personal cost.

Ready to Build Relationships Rooted in Trust? | Therapy for Executives in California & Nevada

As a Pasadena therapist offering online therapy across California and Nevada, I specialize in holistic counseling for executives and high-achieving women who are ready to stop second-guessing themselves and start building relationships rooted in mutual respect.

This work isn't just about identifying trustworthy people - it's about developing the internal compass that helps you trust your own perceptions, set boundaries that actually stick, and show up authentically in relationships without losing yourself in the process.

Whether you're dealing with burnout from over-functioning in relationships, struggling with people-pleasing patterns that leave you feeling invisible, or ready to build the kind of connections that actually nourish you—therapy for executives can help you navigate these changes with clarity and confidence.

Schedule your free consultation and take the first step toward building the relationships you deserve.

Not ready for therapy yet? Stay connected through my newsletter, where I share weekly tools, real-talk about boundaries and burnout, and gentle reminders that your needs matter, too.
Sign up here